Is this cheating?

SOULCALIBUR

Is this cheating?


MATT JO 07-26-2008, 3:50 AM
For the Noble Soul achievement I set it to unlimited time/health and then jus got all ring outs, it wasnt easy, but it wasnt as hard as it would be wit normal settings


Go Gaming Giant - Check out my site.

Twitter: Gogaminggiant

Re: Is this cheating?


Light759 07-27-2008, 4:39 AM
I wouldn't count that as cheating, you still fulfilled the requirements and they would have probably disabled the achivement if the developers though it was cheating to do it that way.

Re: Is this cheating?


XenoFrame V2 07-27-2008, 11:25 AM
It's not cheating, but you didn't " achieve " anything.
This is your life, and it's ending one second at a time.

Re: Is this cheating?


PazyxReborn 07-29-2008, 11:44 AM
In my mind its not quite cheating but its definately close. I done the acheivment with all the settings set to the hardest difficulty (since ive been playing the Soul* series for around a decade) and when I got the acheivment I actually felt like I had acheived something more than just some gamer points or a pretty Icon. Then again it only took me about 3 or 4 minutes from start to finish (did it first time) so I never got frustrated with it.

Re: Is this cheating?


SanguineWing 07-29-2008, 6:08 PM
Nope

Re: Is this cheating?


XenoFrame V2 07-29-2008, 7:43 PM

 PazyxReborn wrote:
In my mind its not quite cheating but its definately close. I done the acheivment with all the settings set to the hardest difficulty (since ive been playing the Soul* series for around a decade) and when I got the acheivment I actually felt like I had acheived something more than just some gamer points or a pretty Icon. Then again it only took me about 3 or 4 minutes from start to finish (did it first time) so I never got frustrated with it.

Touche.


This is your life, and it's ending one second at a time.

Re: Is this cheating?


Arte Venture 07-30-2008, 5:41 AM
LoL! Matt, do you make these threads as jokes? You always feel the need to ask if you are cheating on every game you play. Indifferent [:|]
We lead a blessed life. May it not change; may it not change us.

www.TheOriginalGathering.com

Re: Is this cheating?


F4ceYourFe4rs 07-31-2008, 1:45 AM
That's what I did. It was available, so I did it.
xboxAMBASSADOR
Need help? Just ask! :)

Re: Is this cheating?


Astronaut Bread 08-03-2008, 7:21 PM

Did it feel like cheating?  If it did then, yes, it's cheating.

 

ps- I used this method too after many attempts at getting it legitimately.  I felt bad about it.  I'm over it, but I know I cheated to get it.


Five-Hole.com

Re: Is this cheating?


Elricbro12 08-04-2008, 1:24 PM
I did it. Didn't feel like cheating. I'm just happy i got a hard achievment outta my face but i still have more which ill try to get today.

Re: Is this cheating?


HALOPWNSU 09-15-2008, 5:12 PM

If the options allow you to do it then its not cheating.

Cheating is entering a code or hacking.


I have been banned till 2161.
Mod abuse to the highest power. Just another example of digital fascism.

Re: Is this cheating?


Astronaut Bread 09-17-2008, 4:51 PM
 HALOPWNSU wrote:
If the options allow you to do it then its not cheating.

Cheating is entering a code or hacking.

If you define "cheating" like that then the debate is over, because technically this method wouldn't be "cheating"- but it's still "cheesing."  

Anyways, I think that definition is flawed.  Not many games have codes or hacks, but you can still cheat.  For example, setting the game time and/or penalties in a sports game to off in order to easily get the "get a shut out" or "record 20 blocks" achievements.  The options allow you to do it, but I don't see many people calling that legitimate.

If it feels like cheating, it's cheating... and I cheated to get this Achievement too.  Sad [:(]


Five-Hole.com

Re: Is this cheating?


HALOPWNSU 09-17-2008, 10:01 PM
I think whatever you do to earn an achievement is legit because you at least thought up a way to get it.
I have been banned till 2161.
Mod abuse to the highest power. Just another example of digital fascism.

Re: Is this cheating?


Rattlecat23 10-29-2008, 2:16 PM

The wierdest thing happened to me. I read this thread and thought...hmmmm i'll try that. Got the noble soul achievement...hooray. I went back to the dashboard and checked my played games list to see how many points out of 200 i had. It now reads 0/200. The achievements i've got are coloured in but the scores aren't registering. Any body else had this problem ?

I guess the moral of the story is do things properly or don't do them at all.

Re: Is this cheating?


Rattlecat23 10-29-2008, 2:19 PM
Hmm the plot thickens. If you were to compare achieves with me the scores will show but the noble soul achieve won'tt. This is weird.