Search:
My Xbox

Battlestations™ Midway

Started by certleader at 10-15-2008 12:39 AM. Topic has 60 replies.
Sort Posts:    
Print Search
Page 1 of 3 (61 items)
1 2 3 >

   10-15-2008, 12:39 AM
Reply Quote
best way to kill a BB

I'v just wanted to ask many people this so plz answer and develop the skill. :D

   Report 

   10-16-2008, 6:42 PM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB

Well I would suggest Torps. via either ships or airplanes.

BBs are usually have lots of armor on the deck so bombs shell's don't seem to be very effective.

 

 

   Report 

   10-17-2008, 12:04 AM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
 flyingdragon56 wrote:

Well I would suggest Torps. via either ships or airplanes.

BBs are usually have lots of armor on the deck so bombs shell's don't seem to be very effective.

 

 



You really don't know anything about battleships, do you?



OU SUCKS!
   Report 

   10-18-2008, 2:28 AM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
 Gosnork wrote:
 flyingdragon56 wrote:

Well I would suggest Torps. via either ships or airplanes.

BBs are usually have lots of armor on the deck so bombs shell's don't seem to be very effective.

 

 



You really don't know anything about battleships, do you?


Apparently not.

The USS Johnston charged the Japanese Centre Force by itself. It was a destroyer. I am equally insane over LIVE.
   Report 

   10-19-2008, 11:55 AM
Reply Quote
Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 Gosnork wrote:
 flyingdragon56 wrote:

Well I would suggest Torps. via either ships or airplanes.

BBs are usually have lots of armor on the deck so bombs shell's don't seem to be very effective.

 

 



You really don't know anything about battleships, do you?


Apparently not.
Then why don't you help him out? The most effective way to kill a BB is through the use of torpedoes. That is, however, also the most dangerous method, unless you have a submarine at your command. Just keep in mind that most battleships you encounter haver a top speed either matching or surpassing your submarine's (25kts), so you have one shot at it, making sure both your front and rear torpedoes hit their mark. Also, battleships rarely travel alone, they are accompanied by destroyers equipped with depth-charges which technically is the only thing that can harm you if you play it right. Also, finally, if you only have ships available, make sure you don't attack from one side... and remember, the BB's weakest side is it's front and rear (where the least of it's turrets can fire). If you approach it broadside (directly to it's left or right) you're most likely dead.
Should have stuck with DKIDelta5... ;-)
   Report 

   10-19-2008, 5:10 PM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 Gosnork wrote:
 flyingdragon56 wrote:

Well I would suggest Torps. via either ships or airplanes.

BBs are usually have lots of armor on the deck so bombs shell's don't seem to be very effective.

 

 



You really don't know anything about battleships, do you?


Apparently not.
The most effective way to kill a BB is through the use of torpedoes.

You must only play novice players if you believe this is the best way to kill a battleship.


The USS Johnston charged the Japanese Centre Force by itself. It was a destroyer. I am equally insane over LIVE.
   Report 

   10-19-2008, 6:38 PM
Reply Quote
Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 Gosnork wrote:
 flyingdragon56 wrote:

Well I would suggest Torps. via either ships or airplanes.

BBs are usually have lots of armor on the deck so bombs shell's don't seem to be very effective.

 

 



You really don't know anything about battleships, do you?


Apparently not.
The most effective way to kill a BB is through the use of torpedoes.

You must only play novice players if you believe this is the best way to kill a battleship.

I said the most effective, not the easiest, smart-***. You treat the subject as if it was a well-kept secret. Why don't you just explain to us what (in your opinion) is the best tactic, or would you rather keep it to yourself? At least I'm trying to help the guy, and I know my way works, trial by fire, whichever way you want it.
Should have stuck with DKIDelta5... ;-)
   Report 

   10-20-2008, 2:49 AM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 Gosnork wrote:
 flyingdragon56 wrote:

Well I would suggest Torps. via either ships or airplanes.

BBs are usually have lots of armor on the deck so bombs shell's don't seem to be very effective.

 

 



You really don't know anything about battleships, do you?


Apparently not.
The most effective way to kill a BB is through the use of torpedoes.

You must only play novice players if you believe this is the best way to kill a battleship.

I said the most effective, not the easiest, smart-***. You treat the subject as if it was a well-kept secret. Why don't you just explain to us what (in your opinion) is the best tactic, or would you rather keep it to yourself? At least I'm trying to help the guy, and I know my way works, trial by fire, whichever way you want it.

The most effective way to kill a battleship is with another battleship as long as you're half way decent with your gunnery skill. Torpedoes are laughably under-powered and take a VERY long time to actually sink a unit. The Yamato can basically drain the carrier and airfields of Torpedo planes before it finally goes down. Torpedoes are easy to avoid as well. If a squadron of aircraft are coming your ways and you get hit by two out of three torpedoes, you suck at maneuvering. Another thing to consider is the damage actually done.

Let's say that you get a ship down to 1/4 health using torpedoes. When that ship goes to engage another ship, it will almost be as if those torpedoes never hit you. Why? Because of hull damage. Sure, torpedoes fill you hull up with water and make your ship prettily list to port or you have your stern in the water, but your hull still has 100% armor. Hull integrity is what matters in dive-bombing runs and artillery duels. If you can damage the other players HULL before the battle begins, you have a slight advantage. However, if you are in a gun battle long enough and your hull does go out, then water damage does count.

If you are having trouble with a sub trailing you then you're a dumb-*** who should get off multiplayer right now and play single player for practice. There is almost NEVER an excuse to be having trouble with a sub when you are in a battleship unless you have lost all of your escorts, in which case the game is most likely lost anyways (Even then you can hug the shore. No multiplayer map with battleships and subs together lack a shoreline). If you do have escorts and you're too stupid to send a destroyer after the dude OR launch dive-bombers/torpedo bombers with depth charges to go after the sub, you were bound to lose because your father dropped you on your head as a child.

Same applies to planes. You should be able to see the torp planes coming in from at LEAST three miles away IF you are the only ship. If you have escorts or other units on the map you can see it even further away. This gives you plenty of times to sic your fighters on the attack planes. The only map where a battleship can't have CAP circling overhead is Surigao Straights due to the lack of Japanese carriers or airfields. CAP helps take down a lot of planes, but most battleships have a pretty awesome anti-aircraft arsenal on board (Exception is the Fuso. The only multiplayer map she is on with planes she has awesome cruisers for flak plus destroyers as well so even then there's no excuse.) If by chance you manage to get let's say, SIX, squadrons of planes closing in on you (And this shouldn't happen unless you are the definition of the word 'garbage' or you are one of the last units and the other team has time to set up an attack), they are easy enough to avoid. Just put that baby into reverse and at the right moment and steer her in the right direction. Most of the torpedoes will miss with the exception of the human controlled ones (Unless, once again, the human sucks).

Almost EVERY time I get nailed by another ship's torpedoes, I am not paying attention or am busy battling another ship (Or my buddies are bored and decide to attack a friendly ship for no reason, cough Snork cough). If you're going to plan on using a ship's torpedoes as your primary means to take out a battleship then you're most likely going to be on a short trip to the ocean floor very shortly. Even if you do manage to get the torpedoes to hit (Sometimes torpedoes are well aimed and it's not by chance), like stated before, they are pitifully underpowered.

There are more reasons why but this post is long as it is and I need to get back to what I was doing prior to reading this. Farewell and happy sinking!

EDIT: The only map I would suggest using torpedoes on is Surigao Straights because of the PT boats and terrible battle cruisers that they give you.


The USS Johnston charged the Japanese Centre Force by itself. It was a destroyer. I am equally insane over LIVE.
   Report 

   10-21-2008, 1:16 AM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
The most effective way to kill a BB is through the use of torpedoes.


That cracked me up!

 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
  I said the most effective, not the easiest, smart-***.


How is an easier way not more effective?





OU SUCKS!
   Report 

   10-21-2008, 3:10 PM
Reply Quote
Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
Using the submarine is more effective because not only does it only put itself at risk, but it's also the one unit you have available that can get very close before being detected. But the only way for my method to work is if you take control of the submarine yourself, making it more "effective", but not "easier" because it means handling the submarine on your own. It's pretty easy to send off 12 divebombers carrying 1000 lb bombs and just hoping most of them make it to the target, which essentially is what happens when you use your air-units, because you only fly one plane (out of 4 in the wing). But it's guaranteed that you will lose at lease half a dozen planes against a skilled opponent. In regards to BB vs. BB, it's a 50% chance who wins if you send two equally skilled players against each other, right? What happens to those odds when you send a BB vs. a submarine with the same players against each other? Odds are tipped strongly in favor of the submarine, simply because the BB has no means for self-defence, unless the submarine surfaces.
Should have stuck with DKIDelta5... ;-)
   Report 

   10-21-2008, 5:20 PM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB

 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
What happens to those odds when you send a BB vs. a submarine with the same players against each other? Odds are tipped strongly in favor of the submarine, simply because the BB has no means for self-defence, unless the submarine surfaces.

BB-1, SS-0. That is going to be the end result.

Did you even read my post? Specifically the part about hull damage?There is no excuse for having your battleship being chased by a submarine. The only two multiplayer maps that have both SS and BBs have battle cruisers and 'fast' battleships so to speak (When I say 'fast', I mean BBs that go 25 kt in the game). The SS can't catch up to a BB no matter how hard it tries. Both maps also have shorelines. In the case of Solomon islands, you can see straight away if you enemy launches a submarine. If that is the case you keep the CAs close to the BB and send up some depth charge planes when it comes into range. After the shipyards are down and let's say that they still have one sub lurking around, just put up a couple of sets of fighters for CAP to keep your sonar source alive. Even if it does manage to die, unless the sub has sailed around the island in anticipation of your BB, it won't catch up to you.

On Sybuan(SP) Sea you have so many freaking DDs, if you get sunk by a submarine then you should turn off the power of your box RIGHT NOW. Let's say it surprises you (if this happens you're an idiot) and gets its first wave of torps into you. Have a team mate (Most likely the cruiser teammate) take control of a DD and just play chicken with it. If it even goes to depth three it's screwed and if it breaks off it will never catch back up to the fleet.

On top of this, those two maps have plenty of shoreline and shallows to use against the SS. Just sail close to the shore and the sub will either have to break off or surface. If it decided to trail closely in the deeper section, the player just has to wait until he surfaces.

No matter how you slice it, SS on BB is fail. Gun vs gun is the best way, period.

Listen, just because you like long, hard tubes full of seamen does not make them the best unit in the game to take down battleships.


The USS Johnston charged the Japanese Centre Force by itself. It was a destroyer. I am equally insane over LIVE.
   Report 

   10-21-2008, 5:59 PM
Reply Quote
Sv: Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB

The original poster had no intent on MP advice I believe.

 

And, since I don't even play MP, neither do i!

 

End.


Should have stuck with DKIDelta5... ;-)
   Report 

   10-21-2008, 9:48 PM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:

The original poster had no intent on MP advice I believe.

 

And, since I don't even play MP, neither do i!

 

End.

..... Sinking a battleship in singleplayer on veteran, even in the challenges, is so laughably easy I can't believe somebody would ask for advice to sink one. That is what led me to think that he meant multiplayer. Either way we aren't certain because he never clarifies it.


The USS Johnston charged the Japanese Centre Force by itself. It was a destroyer. I am equally insane over LIVE.
   Report 

   10-22-2008, 11:33 AM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 Gosnork wrote:
 flyingdragon56 wrote:

Well I would suggest Torps. via either ships or airplanes.

BBs are usually have lots of armor on the deck so bombs shell's don't seem to be very effective.

 

 



You really don't know anything about battleships, do you?


Apparently not.
The most effective way to kill a BB is through the use of torpedoes.

You must only play novice players if you believe this is the best way to kill a battleship.

I said the most effective, not the easiest, smart-***. You treat the subject as if it was a well-kept secret. Why don't you just explain to us what (in your opinion) is the best tactic, or would you rather keep it to yourself? At least I'm trying to help the guy, and I know my way works, trial by fire, whichever way you want it.

The most effective way to kill a battleship is with another battleship as long as you're half way decent with your gunnery skill. Torpedoes are laughably under-powered and take a VERY long time to actually sink a unit. The Yamato can basically drain the carrier and airfields of Torpedo planes before it finally goes down. Torpedoes are easy to avoid as well. If a squadron of aircraft are coming your ways and you get hit by two out of three torpedoes, you suck at maneuvering. Another thing to consider is the damage actually done.

Let's say that you get a ship down to 1/4 health using torpedoes. When that ship goes to engage another ship, it will almost be as if those torpedoes never hit you. Why? Because of hull damage. Sure, torpedoes fill you hull up with water and make your ship prettily list to port or you have your stern in the water, but your hull still has 100% armor. Hull integrity is what matters in dive-bombing runs and artillery duels. If you can damage the other players HULL before the battle begins, you have a slight advantage. However, if you are in a gun battle long enough and your hull does go out, then water damage does count.

If you are having trouble with a sub trailing you then you're a dumb-*** who should get off multiplayer right now and play single player for practice. There is almost NEVER an excuse to be having trouble with a sub when you are in a battleship unless you have lost all of your escorts, in which case the game is most likely lost anyways (Even then you can hug the shore. No multiplayer map with battleships and subs together lack a shoreline). If you do have escorts and you're too stupid to send a destroyer after the dude OR launch dive-bombers/torpedo bombers with depth charges to go after the sub, you were bound to lose because your father dropped you on your head as a child.

Same applies to planes. You should be able to see the torp planes coming in from at LEAST three miles away IF you are the only ship. If you have escorts or other units on the map you can see it even further away. This gives you plenty of times to sic your fighters on the attack planes. The only map where a battleship can't have CAP circling overhead is Surigao Straights due to the lack of Japanese carriers or airfields. CAP helps take down a lot of planes, but most battleships have a pretty awesome anti-aircraft arsenal on board (Exception is the Fuso. The only multiplayer map she is on with planes she has awesome cruisers for flak plus destroyers as well so even then there's no excuse.) If by chance you manage to get let's say, SIX, squadrons of planes closing in on you (And this shouldn't happen unless you are the definition of the word 'garbage' or you are one of the last units and the other team has time to set up an attack), they are easy enough to avoid. Just put that baby into reverse and at the right moment and steer her in the right direction. Most of the torpedoes will miss with the exception of the human controlled ones (Unless, once again, the human sucks).

Almost EVERY time I get nailed by another ship's torpedoes, I am not paying attention or am busy battling another ship (Or my buddies are bored and decide to attack a friendly ship for no reason, cough Snork cough). If you're going to plan on using a ship's torpedoes as your primary means to take out a battleship then you're most likely going to be on a short trip to the ocean floor very shortly. Even if you do manage to get the torpedoes to hit (Sometimes torpedoes are well aimed and it's not by chance), like stated before, they are pitifully underpowered.

There are more reasons why but this post is long as it is and I need to get back to what I was doing prior to reading this. Farewell and happy sinking!

EDIT: The only map I would suggest using torpedoes on is Surigao Straights because of the PT boats and terrible battle cruisers that they give you.

 

All greats points as ever Dremora!    

 

 

Very good description of killing a battleship by all the available means!

The best way to kill a BB is with another BB.  End of.

   Report 

   10-22-2008, 11:37 AM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB

 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
In regards to BB vs. BB, it's a 50% chance who wins if you send two equally skilled players against each other, right?

 

Obviously if the two players are EQUALLY matched then there will be the likelihood that 2 matches would yield a victory for each player.

However, this very rarely happens anymore, especially with the level of skill shown by most of the players at the moment.  18montrhs ago when ALL the good players still played it would have been a likely scenario!

 

The way things are at the moment if I go into a room and dont know anyone then I will snap the disc and never ever play the game again if I lose my BB lol

   Report 

   10-22-2008, 11:39 AM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB

 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
Using the submarine is more effective because not only does it only put itself at risk, but it's also the one unit you have available that can get very close before being detected. But the only way for my method to work is if you take control of the submarine yourself, making it more "effective", but not "easier" because it means handling the submarine on your own. It's pretty easy to send off 12 divebombers carrying 1000 lb bombs and just hoping most of them make it to the target, which essentially is what happens when you use your air-units, because you only fly one plane (out of 4 in the wing). But it's guaranteed that you will lose at lease half a dozen planes against a skilled opponent. In regards to BB vs. BB, it's a 50% chance who wins if you send two equally skilled players against each other, right? What happens to those odds when you send a BB vs. a submarine with the same players against each other? Odds are tipped strongly in favor of the submarine, simply because the BB has no means for self-defence, unless the submarine surfaces.

 

I just wanted to put this to you - baring in mind your last post about not playing MP.........

 

 

Looking at this post you have made it is clear that you do play some degree of MP.......

 

 

If you cant sink a BB on SP then you should go back to playing Halo.

   Report 

   10-22-2008, 1:16 PM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
 Bucky O Hare69 wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 Gosnork wrote:
 flyingdragon56 wrote:

Well I would suggest Torps. via either ships or airplanes.

BBs are usually have lots of armor on the deck so bombs shell's don't seem to be very effective.

 

 



You really don't know anything about battleships, do you?


Apparently not.
The most effective way to kill a BB is through the use of torpedoes.

You must only play novice players if you believe this is the best way to kill a battleship.

I said the most effective, not the easiest, smart-***. You treat the subject as if it was a well-kept secret. Why don't you just explain to us what (in your opinion) is the best tactic, or would you rather keep it to yourself? At least I'm trying to help the guy, and I know my way works, trial by fire, whichever way you want it.

The most effective way to kill a battleship is with another battleship as long as you're half way decent with your gunnery skill. Torpedoes are laughably under-powered and take a VERY long time to actually sink a unit. The Yamato can basically drain the carrier and airfields of Torpedo planes before it finally goes down. Torpedoes are easy to avoid as well. If a squadron of aircraft are coming your ways and you get hit by two out of three torpedoes, you suck at maneuvering. Another thing to consider is the damage actually done.

Let's say that you get a ship down to 1/4 health using torpedoes. When that ship goes to engage another ship, it will almost be as if those torpedoes never hit you. Why? Because of hull damage. Sure, torpedoes fill you hull up with water and make your ship prettily list to port or you have your stern in the water, but your hull still has 100% armor. Hull integrity is what matters in dive-bombing runs and artillery duels. If you can damage the other players HULL before the battle begins, you have a slight advantage. However, if you are in a gun battle long enough and your hull does go out, then water damage does count.

If you are having trouble with a sub trailing you then you're a dumb-*** who should get off multiplayer right now and play single player for practice. There is almost NEVER an excuse to be having trouble with a sub when you are in a battleship unless you have lost all of your escorts, in which case the game is most likely lost anyways (Even then you can hug the shore. No multiplayer map with battleships and subs together lack a shoreline). If you do have escorts and you're too stupid to send a destroyer after the dude OR launch dive-bombers/torpedo bombers with depth charges to go after the sub, you were bound to lose because your father dropped you on your head as a child.

Same applies to planes. You should be able to see the torp planes coming in from at LEAST three miles away IF you are the only ship. If you have escorts or other units on the map you can see it even further away. This gives you plenty of times to sic your fighters on the attack planes. The only map where a battleship can't have CAP circling overhead is Surigao Straights due to the lack of Japanese carriers or airfields. CAP helps take down a lot of planes, but most battleships have a pretty awesome anti-aircraft arsenal on board (Exception is the Fuso. The only multiplayer map she is on with planes she has awesome cruisers for flak plus destroyers as well so even then there's no excuse.) If by chance you manage to get let's say, SIX, squadrons of planes closing in on you (And this shouldn't happen unless you are the definition of the word 'garbage' or you are one of the last units and the other team has time to set up an attack), they are easy enough to avoid. Just put that baby into reverse and at the right moment and steer her in the right direction. Most of the torpedoes will miss with the exception of the human controlled ones (Unless, once again, the human sucks).

Almost EVERY time I get nailed by another ship's torpedoes, I am not paying attention or am busy battling another ship (Or my buddies are bored and decide to attack a friendly ship for no reason, cough Snork cough). If you're going to plan on using a ship's torpedoes as your primary means to take out a battleship then you're most likely going to be on a short trip to the ocean floor very shortly. Even if you do manage to get the torpedoes to hit (Sometimes torpedoes are well aimed and it's not by chance), like stated before, they are pitifully underpowered.

There are more reasons why but this post is long as it is and I need to get back to what I was doing prior to reading this. Farewell and happy sinking!

EDIT: The only map I would suggest using torpedoes on is Surigao Straights because of the PT boats and terrible battle cruisers that they give you.

 

All greats points as ever Dremora!    

 

 

Very good description of killing a battleship by all the available means!

The best way to kill a BB is with another BB.  End of.

What can I say? I know my Battlestations! Big Smile [:D]

"I just wanted to put this to you - baring in mind your last post about not playing MP.........

 

 

Looking at this post you have made it is clear that you do play some degree of MP.......

 

 

If you cant sink a BB on SP then you should go back to playing Halo."

Hey, didn't even realize that. I was so tired when I read it I probably just skimmed over it!


The USS Johnston charged the Japanese Centre Force by itself. It was a destroyer. I am equally insane over LIVE.
   Report 

   10-22-2008, 1:26 PM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:

The original poster had no intent on MP advice I believe.

 

And, since I don't even play MP, neither do i!

 

End.



If you had any credibility on the subject, you would have lost it right there.



OU SUCKS!
   Report 

   10-22-2008, 4:17 PM
Reply Quote
Re: Sv: Re: Sv: Re: best way to kill a BB
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 Bucky O Hare69 wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 UNIT Headhunter wrote:
 Dremora Warlord wrote:
 Gosnork wrote:
 flyingdragon56 wrote:

Well I would suggest Torps. via either ships or airplanes.

BBs are usually have lots of armor on the deck so bombs shell's don't seem to be very effective.

 

 



You really don't know anything about battleships, do you?


Apparently not.
The most effective way to kill a BB is through the use of torpedoes.

You must only play novice players if you believe this is the best way to kill a battleship.

I said the most effective, not the easiest, smart-***. You treat the subject as if it was a well-kept secret. Why don't you just explain to us what (in your opinion) is the best tactic, or would you rather keep it to yourself? At least I'm trying to help the guy, and I know my way works, trial by fire, whichever way you want it.

The most effective way to kill a battleship is with another battleship as long as you're half way decent with your gunnery skill. Torpedoes are laughably under-powered and take a VERY long time to actually sink a unit. The Yamato can basically drain the carrier and airfields of Torpedo planes before it finally goes down. Torpedoes are easy to avoid as well. If a squadron of aircraft are coming your ways and you get hit by two out of three torpedoes, you suck at maneuvering. Another thing to consider is the damage actually done.

Let's say that you get a ship down to 1/4 health using torpedoes. When that ship goes to engage another ship, it will almost be as if those torpedoes never hit you. Why? Because of hull damage. Sure, torpedoes fill you hull up with water and make your ship prettily list to port or you have your stern in the water, but your hull still has 100% armor. Hull integrity is what matters in dive-bombing runs and artillery duels. If you can damage the other players HULL before the battle begins, you have a slight advantage. However, if you are in a gun battle long enough and your hull does go out, then water damage does count.

If you are having trouble with a sub trailing you then you're a dumb-*** who should get off multiplayer right now and play single player for practice. There is almost NEVER an excuse to be having trouble with a sub when you are in a battleship unless you have lost all of your escorts, in which case the game is most likely lost anyways (Even then you can hug the shore. No multiplayer map with battleships and subs together lack a shoreline). If you do have escorts and you're too stupid to send a destroyer after the dude OR launch dive-bombers/torpedo bombers with depth charges to go after the sub, you were bound to lose because your father dropped you on your head as a child.

Same applies to planes. You should be able to see the torp planes coming in from at LEAST three miles away IF you are the only ship. If you have escorts or other units on the map you can see it even further away. This gives you plenty of times to sic your fighters on the attack planes. The only map where a battleship can't have CAP circling overhead is Surigao Straights due to the lack of Japanese carriers or airfields. CAP helps take down a lot of planes, but most battleships have a pretty awesome anti-aircraft arsenal on board (Exception is the Fuso. The only multiplayer map she is on with planes she has awesome cruisers for flak plus destroyers as well so even then there's no excuse.) If by chance you manage to get let's say, SIX, squadrons of planes closing in on you (And this shouldn't happen unless you are the definition of the word 'garbage' or you are one of the last units and the other team has time to set up an attack), they are easy enough to avoid. Just put that baby into reverse and at the right moment and steer her in the right direction. Most of the torpedoes will miss with the exception of the human controlled ones (Unless, once again, the human sucks).

Almost EVERY time I get nailed by another ship's torpedoes, I am not paying attention or am busy battling another ship (Or my buddies are bored and decide to attack a friendly ship for no reason, cough Snork cough). If you're going to plan on using a ship's torpedoes as your primary means to take out a battleship then you're most likely going to be on a short trip to the ocean floor very shortly. Even if you do manage to get the torpedoes to hit (Sometimes torpedoes are well aimed and it's not by chance), like stated before, they are pitifully underpowered.

There are more reasons why but this post is long as it is and I need to get back to what I was doing prior to reading this. Farewell and happy sinking!

EDIT: The only map I would suggest using torpedoes on is Surigao Straights because of the PT boats and terrible battle cruisers that they give you.

 

All greats points as ever Dremora!    

 

 

Very good description of killing a battleship by all the available means!

The best way to kill a BB is with another BB.  End of.

What can I say? I know my Battlestations! Big Smile [:D]

 

hahahaha you really do mate  Smile [:)]

   Report 

   11-10-2008, 10:44 AM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
dang people i just wanted how everybody does it cuzz everyone has their own way of doing it i can kill 3 BBs extremo fast it isn't hard at all dang...
   Report 

   11-11-2008, 1:42 PM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB

 certleader wrote:
dang people i just wanted how everybody does it cuzz everyone has their own way of doing it i can kill 3 BBs extremo fast it isn't hard at all dang...

Then why the *** did you ask? You didn't ask "How do you kill a BB?", you asked us "The best way to kill a BB". 

You also wouldn't say it's easy if you played any of the old veterans such as myself, Snork, or other old-timers.


The USS Johnston charged the Japanese Centre Force by itself. It was a destroyer. I am equally insane over LIVE.
   Report 

   11-15-2008, 6:06 AM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
so what.... oyea im crazyer than you try pt vs a lot of other DDs aircraft carriers and a BB im not just nuts im crazy dumb @## nuts man waaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhooooooooooooooooooooooooo
   Report 

   11-15-2008, 6:16 AM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB

 certleader wrote:
so what.... oyea im crazyer than you try pt vs a lot of other DDs aircraft carriers and a BB im not just nuts im crazy dumb @## nuts man waaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhooooooooooooooooooooooooo

If I knew what you were trying to say I would intelligently reply, but I'm afraid I can't do so.


The USS Johnston charged the Japanese Centre Force by itself. It was a destroyer. I am equally insane over LIVE.
   Report 

   11-28-2008, 3:26 AM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
Just torp te Battleship till it goes down
   Report 

   12-01-2008, 9:51 PM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
there are many reasons that i will not name but only 3 about why that isn't a good idea 1. too much time is used the hull is very hard 2. too many ships and or planes will be taken out 3.you probley wount win the battle if there are more ships if the 2nd reason accures so yea thanks for the post tho.
   Report 

   12-02-2008, 2:31 AM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
 certleader wrote:
there are many reasons that i will not name


No, you don't have to because I have already posted almost every reason.

The USS Johnston charged the Japanese Centre Force by itself. It was a destroyer. I am equally insane over LIVE.
   Report 

   12-09-2008, 12:52 AM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
I hate to be like this but o well. TRY SHOOTING IT!!! Just a thought.:)

How to tether the iPhone to your Xbox!!! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O9hwRhNcsV4

   Report 

   12-09-2008, 12:30 PM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
 certleader wrote:
there are many reasons that i will not name but only 3 about why that isn't a good idea 1. too much time is used the hull is very hard 2. too many ships and or planes will be taken out 3.you probley wount win the battle if there are more ships if the 2nd reason accures so yea thanks for the post tho.
OK let me get this through you peoples heads, if you have a destroyer you have speed on your side + TORPS, If you stick 4 well placed torps on the Yamoto It will go down on any ship you'll only have to stick a maximum of 4 torps to sink a ship if you dont think its such a good idea i dare you to try it and you'll win every level
   Report 

   12-09-2008, 1:07 PM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
 SRthekiller wrote:
 certleader wrote:
there are many reasons that i will not name but only 3 about why that isn't a good idea 1. too much time is used the hull is very hard 2. too many ships and or planes will be taken out 3.you probley wount win the battle if there are more ships if the 2nd reason accures so yea thanks for the post tho.
OK let me get this through you peoples heads, if you have a destroyer you have speed on your side + TORPS, If you stick 4 well placed torps on the Yamoto It will go down on any ship you'll only have to stick a maximum of 4 torps to sink a ship if you dont think its such a good idea i dare you to try it and you'll win every level


Your joking right????

4 torps will sink the yamato??  In your dreams my friend.
   Report 

   12-09-2008, 3:15 PM
Reply Quote
Re: best way to kill a BB
 Bucky O Hare69 wrote:
 SRthekiller wrote:
 certleader wrote:
there are many reasons that i will not name but only 3 about why that isn't a good idea 1. too much time is used the hull is very hard 2. too many ships and or planes will be taken out 3.you probley wount win the battle if there are more ships if the 2nd reason accures so yea thanks for the post tho.
OK let me get this through you peoples heads, if you have a destroyer you have speed on your side + TORPS, If you stick 4 well placed torps on the Yamoto It will go down on any ship you'll only have to stick a maximum of 4 torps to sink a ship if you dont think its such a good idea i dare you to try it and you'll win every level


Your joking right????

4 torps will sink the yamato??  In your dreams my friend.


Well, do to the fact that this fool has a silver account, I think he means single player. But it still doesn't make sense if it is single player, because there is no map where you have a DD and the enemy has a BB in single player, not even the challenge missions... I don't know what he's talking about.

I say we play him online, destroy him, and prove him wrong. Sound like a plan?

The USS Johnston charged the Japanese Centre Force by itself. It was a destroyer. I am equally insane over LIVE.
   Report 
Page 1 of 3 (61 items)
1 2 3 >

©2009 Microsoft Corporation. All Rights Reserved