Incorrect. To me a 10 out of 10 means that the game is the best that it possibly could be, and I don't see the mentioned issues to bring it down by any standards. You play the game the WAY you were expected to *traditional Sonic + Werehog Sonic* and if it's the most fun you've had, then why score lower? Simple as that
I understand what are you talking about, but if the game didn´t have any kind of issues, wouldn´t you score it better? I mean, this game could be better, or even funnier. It can be improved in many ways. In fact, I think the next Sonic game will use this same engine, and will probably have better gameplay.
So if I played a game and there were framerate issues *examples of games I have played: FEAR, Ninja Gaiden 2* that gives me a legitimate reason to downplay it only because it's not running as smoothly? Please
Yeah, that´s an issue. Come on, it´s not a small framerate issue. There are parts in the Adabat level that are nearly unplayable. I don´t see many games that have the same problem.
To also point out that past systems wouldn't lag like that is a pretty big assumption considering how much power is behind trying to render so many things at once. Past systems wouldn't have this issue because they wouldn't have NEARLY as much to render, much less deal with onscreen!
Wrong. Slowdown could exist since every 3D game that has been made (and even 2D games). But developers have to code the engine of the game and do the design of the levels so they look good and they don´t slow down. If you want a recent slowdown, you can try Speed Highway with Sonic in Sonic Adventure DX from GameCube. The game slows down when you reach the last part of the level, near the end capsule.
You can´t just put thousands of things in screen, then try it on a system, and reaching the market, even with serious slowdowns. That´s not how game making works.
Just take a look at the Wii/PS2 versions of this same game. It looks HORRIBLE. The very first time I laid eyes on video of the levels I felt as if I was physically molested *although I laughed* because of how utterly...MINDLESS it is. And to think that those versions, especially the Wii version, that are rated higher. It makes my blood absolutely boil.
I totally agree with you in this one. Wii/PS2 versions doesn´t reserve to score high. And I think too that many reviewers didn´t ever give a chance to the game. As I said, the game have some issues, and there are other things that could score down the game, but come on, there are even sites that reviewed Sonic 06 with better score.
Not the machine's fault...hmm. The more and more I keep playing the PS3 version I really doubt this. BUT, everyone's entitled to their own opinion. Just to point it out there, Cool Edge runs gorgeously in full frame with PS3 hardware backing it up, holy crap.
And what do that means? That developers haven´t made their work doing the game in the Xbox360 version. There are many hardware differences between Xbox360 and PS3, and you have to code each of the versions with that in mind. And really, do you think that some polygonal rocks that fall on the water can slowdown by themselves a system like the 360?? They just have some wrong code that is making the slowdown. And I´m sure it´s something not that hard to fix, but either they have forgotten to do so, or they didn´t have the time to do it.
Doesn't happen in other areas or acts? Really. *takes a peek some of the Night levels as well as Mazuri's Savannah Citadel*
Well, not at less than 10fps like Adabat. It´s bad too, but at least it doesn´t require to go at full speed while it´s happening. Anyway, both of them shouldn´t happen.
As I've stated before, I don't find issues like these that were mentioned to be SERIOUS as to put so much emphasis on them to me, is futile and real childish. So this is why I get at people who appear as such, though I'm glad you're not like this.
Don´t worry, I get your point and I think you have got mine too. This game is better than most 3D Sonic games out there, and still it have scored less than many of them. I just think there are some issues that could be solved and weren´t, and it´s a pitty because this game could have been a lot better just by fixing them.
Anyway, if the rumour of the next Sonic game is true, we will see something as good or better than this game after a year or two. It will surely use the Hedgehog engine, and it will surely be similar to Day Acts of Unleashed, so we will see how do they improve the gameplay, and if reviewers are way off again or not.