I found Doom 3 to be scary because of the feeling of being cut of completely from everything else. Being stranded on a lifeless Mars with demons everywhere in a dark station is a frightening prospect. On earth the theme would change. It would be more like Dawn of the Dead or Resident Evil where the communities are populated with zombies and demons. A lot of thought would have to go into making Doom 4 on Earth.
Tom
http://stores.shop.ebay.com/Space-Station-Video-Games