LO reminds me a lot of Final Fantasy 7 in terms of atmosphere, and Final Fantasy 9 in terms of gameplay. The only thing that I could think that MIGHT turn people away from this game is the excessive storytelling. The "excessive" point can be different depending on your tolerance to storytelling, as most of your first 5 hours in the game will be spent watching the story unfold as opposed to dipping in to the combat. If you like story driven RPGs (and LO has a pretty fantastic storyline from what I've played so far) with a classic turn-based combat system, it should be right up your alley.
Looking forward to - COD:MW2, Left 4 Dead 2, BioShock 2, FF13, Mass Effect 2