This is horseshit I got two good henchmen and waited till midnight because that is the time you are suppose to wait for when your pure evil right, and so this stupid skorm worshiper keeps saying my offers suck and im about to break my xbox in half please help!

Get the merc from the Temple of Avo and another merc, I usually have one more person follow me (villager) wait til just before midnight and then right at midnight, then after midnight. You will know because the merc takes money right at midnight.