I totally 100% agree with ragingstorm22 - I want a prequel! I LOVED John, but Jack? Whiny little horse abusing, high pitched baby! (Did anyone else notice he had a deeper voice as a teenager than he did as an adult?!)
I hope Rockstar does a prequel that shows a younger John in the gang, meeting Abigail (maybe even playing as Abigail sometimes?), showing how they met, and then showing the falling out with the gang. Maybe even showing us how he got that distinctive facial scar? I also think it could be interesting to have a bigger dynamic in fight scenes, where you're fighting people with all of Dutch's gang at your side. Seeing Dutch's downfall & descent into insanity would be fascinating as well. And the whole love story angle would be interesting for me, though I am a girl. :)
But yeah, more John please! Less Jack! Or if they want to go entirely different & come up with new characters and a new story, like they did between Revolver and Redemption, that'd be fine with me. All I hope for is that the writing retains its amazing quality & the gameplay continues to be outstanding! Heck, maybe they could even go back in time to an earlier stage of the American west. I'd be fine with that too!
Heck, honestly, I'd be fine with anything... as long as I get more high quality Red Dead!!! It's by far the best game I have ever, ever played. Period. End of story.